Arbitration
With rbitrage, procedure of payment of a litigation by
people named by the parts in order to slice a disagreement. The arbitration,
which is presented in the form of an alternative solution at traditional
justice, is used more and more by the companies in commercial matters. This
possibility tends to develop, as well at the national level as international,
because of the advantages which it has at the glance procedures carried in
front of the traditional courts.
The first advantage of the arbitration is in the
possibility offered to the parts to choose their referees according to a
certain number of criteria, which can vary according to litigations' to
solve.The second advantage is due to the simplification of the procedure,
insofar as the parts exempt the referees to respect the formalism imposed by
the legal procedure.
In addition to its speed and its economic character,
the arbitration offers the advantage of discretion, since the referees, who do
not deliberate in public, are held to respect an obligation of confidentiality.
The sentences (legal term given to the arbitration decisions) delivered by the
referees, unlike the stops or of the judgements given by the courses and the
courts, are not the subject of any publication.
The recourse to the arbitration is also appreciated at
the international level, because it avoids with the parts of different
nationalities carrying their litigation in front of jurisdictions whose
language and procedure are generally obscure for them, even unknown.
Lastly, even if one of the parts obtains a decision of
court which consolidates the defense of its interests, it is likely to encounter
difficulties to enforce this judgement in the country of the opposing party,
because the procedure of recognition of the foreign judgements is particularly
complex in the absence of International Convention in this field. Contrary, the
arbitration decision is often well accepted by the parts, which more easily
carry out in fact the decision which puts a term at the litigation which
opposes them.
There exists however, of the fields in which its
recourse is prohibited, in particular for all that concerns the law and order, heard like the legal organization of the life
in company. Thus, for example, the arbitration is interdict in all the matters
which control the state and the capacity of the people (marriage, divorce,
filiation). In the field of the trade, the arbitration cannot apply as regards
legal rectification of a company and thus come to replace the action of the
commercial courts, the matter concerned with the law and order known as
economic.On the other hand, there or it has vocation to apply, the arbitration
developed considerably: if it should not inevitably be apprehended as
competitor at the other techniques of the right which have the aim of settling
a disagreement, the arbitration presents the merit of the effectiveness and the
speed. The recourse to the arbitration can be decided either in preparation for
the supervening of the litigation, or subsequently to its realization.First of
all, the parts with a contract can decide to resort to the arbitration as of
the negotiation and the drafting of the contract while inserting there what the
right names a "arbitration clause". To be juridically valid, this
clause must be written and to make appear, if not the identity of the referees,
at least the methods of their designation.
Although used in a preoccupation with a precaution,
such a clause present of the dangers to the people not very ready to seize the
exact range of it. This is why the arbitration clause is licit only in
commercial matters, i.e. when it relates to contracts concluded between
tradesmen or companies, namely of the people presumedly able to defend their
interests during a negotiation of businesses. This restriction is likely to
protect the interests from the neophytes, and thus to avoid the economic abuses
power.
The parts can also have recourse to the arbitration
after the supervening of the litigation, when those are intended in order to
establish a compromise of arbitration. This one, to be valid, in particular
requires (as for the arbitration clause) to be noted in writing, which having
to specify the nature of the litigation to be solved, the identity of the
referees and the methods of their designation.
The arbitration jurisdiction can be made up of only
one or several referees, always in an odd number. Generally, the arbitration
jurisdictions comprise three referees, so that each part (generally two) can
designate a referee, which choose the third then. The referees are physical
people, selected on lists drawn up by centers of arbitration, which generally
depend on the Chambers of Commerce and Industry. The referees are held with the
respect of the principle of the contradictory one, which means that they must
convene the parts and invite them to present their arguments and means of
defense, and to also take care that each one can know the content of the
arguments of right which are opposite for him (it is the principle of the
communication of the parts). Lastly, the referees must justify their decision,
i.e. to indicate the reasons of right which justify the conclusions of their
decision.
The award results from a secret deliberation of the
referees, adopted in the majority of the voices. The sentence is analyzed in a
true decision of court which profits from the authority of the final decision
and thus prevents the parts from carrying the same litigation in front of a
court. However, it does not profit from the executory force attached to a
judgement or a stop. The execution of the award thus rests for a share on the
volunteer tender of the parts, which recognize the legal authenticity of the
award
In the event of non-observance, by one or the other of
the parts, the award, it is then necessary to require the distraint of it. In
the case of France, this competence belongs to the Court of Bankruptcy, whose
task consists in checking the formal regularity of the convention and the
arbitration. The judge cannot examine the business at the bottom, it can return
only one decision of exequatur, allowing the part which intends to be prevailed of
the arbitration decision to force its adversary to subject itself to it.
Aucun commentaire:
Enregistrer un commentaire